August 1, 2024
Lead’s neurotoxicity is well established, and organophosphate pesticides were deliberately developed first as nerve agents in warfare and then as insecticides.
Noting that “Epidemiologic research on chemical exposures associated with the development of ADHD is numerous; however, studies have employed various methods, and, in some cases, have resulted in seemingly conflicting results,” a U.S. study team has performed an updated meta-analysis applying “identical meta-analytic techniques to the literature on the associations between earlier chemical exposures and later ADHD.”
Lead
Meta-analysis of eleven studies reporting dichotomous outcomes with a combined 7,566 participants found children exposed to lead were almost twice as likely to subsequently be diagnosed with ADHD as their unexposed peers.
A second meta-analysis, of thirteen studies reporting continuous outcomes with a total of 1,775 participants, found a small effect size increase in ADHD diagnosis from exposure to lead.
Interestingly, meta-analysis of four studies with a combined 4,360 participants found no association between prenatal lead exposure and subsequent ADHD diagnosis.
On the other hand, meta-analysis of seven studies combining almost five thousand participants reported that cumulative lead exposure more than doubled the likelihood of subsequent ADHD.
In other words, it’s not so much prenatal exposure as exposure after birth that is associated with increased risk.
Organophosphates
Meta-analysis of four studies reporting continuous outcomes with a combined total of 692 persons likewise found a small effect size increase in ADHD diagnosis from exposure to organophosphates.
Mercury
Meta-analysis of six studies reporting continuous outcomes with a combined total of over 17 thousand participants found a tiny effect size increase in ADHD diagnosis from exposure to mercury.
On the other hand, meta-analysis of ten studies reporting dichotomous outcomes with a combined total of over 650,000 persons found no association whatsoever between mercury exposure and subsequent diagnosis of ADHD.
Other exposures
Meta-analysis of five studies involving more than 34,000 participants found no evidence of an association between exposure to anesthesia and ADHD.
Meta-analysis of three studies encompassing 1,739 individuals found no evidence of an association between exposure to cadmium and ADHD.
Meta-analysis of four studies combining more than 2,400 persons found no evidence of an association between exposure to hexachlorobenzene and ADHD.
A pair of meta-analyses, one of three studies reporting dichotomous outcomes including 2,050 participants, the other of nine studies reporting continuous outcomes involving almost three thousand participants, both found no evidence of an association between exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and ADHD.
There was little variability (heterogeneity) among results reported by individual studies within these meta-analyses, but a serious limitation was the failure to check for publication bias.
The authors concluded, “given our findings related to exposure to mercury, organophosphates, and PCBs, further research may be helpful to better characterize these relationships. Many of our effect sizes were small, which is consistent with the literature indicating that many genetic and environmental factors contribute to ADHD. … Furthermore, our findings support existing regulations of certain chemicals,” and “may inform future regulatory decisions”
Lina V. Dimitrov, Jennifer W. Kaminski, Joseph R. Holbrook, Rebecca H. Bitsko, Michael Yeh, Joseph G. Courtney, Brenna O’Masta, Brion Maher, Audrey Cerles, Katherine McGowan, and Margaret Rush, “A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Chemical Exposures and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in Children,” Prevention Science (2024), 25 (Suppl 2):S225–S248, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11121-023-01601-6.
A meta-analysis of short-term, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trials (Cortese et al. 2018), looking at both efficacy and safety, supported prescribing stimulants – methylphenidate use in children and adolescents and amphetamine use in adults – as first-choice medications.
However, these were short-term studies, and they focused on relieving ADHD symptoms. What about longer-term outcomes, especially looking more broadly at functional impairment and overall quality of life?
Sweden has a single-payer health insurance system that encompasses virtually every resident and is linked to national registers that enable researchers to conduct nationwide population studies.
A joint Finnish-Swedish research team used Sweden’s registers to study outcomes for all individuals of working age, 16 to 65 years old, living in Sweden who had received a diagnosis of ADHD from 2006 through 2021. The resulting study cohort encompassed 221,714 persons with ADHD.
The team adjusted for the following confounding variables: Genetics, baseline severity of symptoms, baseline comorbidities, temporal order of treatments (which medication was used as first, second, third, and so forth, including also nonuse of ADHD medications), time since cohort entry, and time-varying use of psychotropic drugs, including antidepressants, anxiolytics, hypnotics, mood stabilizers (carbamazepine, valproic acid, and lamotrigine), lithium, antipsychotics, and drugs for addictive disorders.
With these adjustments, they discovered that amphetamine treatment was associated with a roughly 25% reduction in psychiatric hospitalization relative to unmedicated ADHD. Lisdexamphetamine was associated with a roughly 20% reduction, dexamphetamine with a 12% reduction, and methylphenidate with a 7% reduction. All four medications are stimulants.
None of the non-stimulant medications – atomoxetine, guanfacine, clonidine – had any significant effect on psychiatric hospitalization. Nor did modafinil a drug that is not FDA approved for ADHD but is sometimes used when other drugs fail.
Amphetamine was also associated with the greatest reduction in suicide attempts or deaths, with a roughly 40% decline relative to unmedicated ADHD. Dexamphetamine was associated with a roughly 30% decline and lisdexamphetamine with a roughly 25% decline. The stimulant methylphenidate was only associated with an 8% reduction, and modafinil had no significant effect.
Surprisingly, non-stimulant medications were associated with significant increases in suicide attempts or deaths: 20% for atomoxetine, 65% for guanfacine, and almost double for clonidine.
Amphetamine and lisdexamphetamine also reduced the risk of nonpsychiatric hospitalization by more than a third compared to unmedicated ADHD. Dexamphetamine was associated with a risk reduction of more than 25%, methylphenidate with 20% lesser risk.
The non-stimulant atomoxetine was associated with a roughly 15% reduction in risk of nonpsychiatric hospitalization. But neither guanfacine nor clonidine had any significant effect.
Turning to work disability, atomoxetine was the only ADHD medication associated with a reduction – a roughly 10% improvement. All other medications had no significant effect.
The team concluded, “In this cohort study of adolescents and adults with ADHD, the use of medications for ADHD, especially lisdexamphetamine and other stimulants, was associated with decreased risk of psychiatric hospitalizations, suicidal behavior, and nonpsychiatric hospitalizations during periods when they were used compared with periods when ADHD medication was not used. Non-stimulant atomoxetine use was associated with decreased risk of work disability.”
Noting that “Oxidative stress disrupts the structure and function of neurons in the prefrontal lobe of the brain,” and “Structural and functional impairments in the prefrontal cortex have been shown to be highly correlated with behavioral and emotional problems of ADHD,” a Chinese team at Dalian University set out to systematically evaluate the safety and efficacy of antioxidant therapy in children and adolescents with ADHD.
The team’s systematic search of the peer-reviewed medical literature identified a total of 48 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) or prospective studies involving 12 antioxidant agents (resveratrol, pycnogenol, omega-3, omega-6, quercetin, phosphatidylserine, almond, vitamin D, zinc, folic acid, ginkgo biloba, Acetyl-L-carnitine) that met criteria for inclusion:
Treatment efficacy was measured through ADHD symptom scores using Conners’ parent rating scale (CPRS), Conners’ teacher rating scale (CTRS), ADHD rating scale-parent (ADHD RS-Parent), and ADHD rating scale-teacher (ADHD RS-Teacher), as well as secondary outcome indicators such as the Clinical Global Impressions scale (CGI) and Continuous Performance Test (CPT), relative to controls.
None of the antioxidant therapies were significantly better than placebo.
One limitation is that no effort was made to assess publication bias.
These results indicate that antioxidants should not be used for treating ADHD.
A 2021 consensus statement by an international group of scientists and clinicians (Bauer et al.) recommended that pregnant individuals “forego [acetaminophen] unless its use is medically indicated,” due to the potential risk of developmental disorders such as autism and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
A mostly Swedish research team, collaborating with a U.S. researcher, nevertheless noted that previous studies have been limited by:
Sweden has a single-payer health insurance system that includes virtually its entire population, and national registers that enable tracking the health history of mothers and their children, including their children’s siblings.
The team used the Swedish registers to identify the roughly two-and-a-half million children born in Sweden from mid-1995 through 2019. They were also able to identify all siblings to be able to control for otherwise unmeasured familial and genetic confounding.
Almost 186,000 of these children were exposed to acetaminophen during pregnancy.
After adjusting for available known confounders, including (but not limited to) child sex and birthdate, mother’s age and medical history, use of any other painkillers, use of any psychoactive medications, country of birth, residential region, smoking status, highest household education, and disposable income, children exposed to acetaminophen during pregnancy were 7% more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD subsequently than those who were not exposed.
However, roughly the same results were found for other painkillers, including aspirin, non-aspirin nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), opioids, and antimigraine medication. High doses of acetaminophen did not produce any stronger association with subsequent ADHD than low dosage.
Moreover, when confining results to siblings – 8,526 children who were exposed versus 87,679 who were unexposed – the association between acetaminophen use during pregnancy and subsequent offspring ADHD vanished altogether (and, again, at every dose level). The associations similarly vanished with every other painkiller medication.
The Swedish team concluded, “Acetaminophen use during pregnancy was not associated with children’s risk of autism, ADHD, or intellectual disability in sibling control analyses. This suggests that associations observed in models without sibling control may have been attributable to confounding.”
_logo%201.svg)
